About these ads

Now Playing: A Touch of Sin

A Touch of Sin
Dir: Jia Zhang-ke, China, 2013
Rating: 9.9

“I’m not an admirer of the kind of films that Zhang Yimou makes. I much prefer Jia Zhang-ke’s films, like Still Life and I Wish I Knew.”

– Chinese President Xi Jinping, quoted by Tony Rayns in Film Comment


Now playing at the Music Box Theatre is A Touch of Sin, the latest from maverick Chinese director Jia Zhang-ke. This angry, provocative, disturbing and beautiful anthology film, consisting of four loosely linked vignettes, represents a triumphant return to narrative filmmaking for Jia, the most important member of the Chinese film industry’s “sixth generation.” It is the director’s first purely fictional feature since Still Life in 2006 (following a period in which he has made numerous documentaries and shorts, and one narrative/documentary hybrid, 2008’s 24 City). It is also my favorite of Jia’s movies to date and one that has convinced me to go back and revisit his entire filmography. While I was blown away by Jia’s masterful, Beijing theme-park-set epic The World in 2004, the first of his films I ever saw, I’ve had decidedly mixed feelings about all of the others, which I now concede may represent a failure of both comprehension and taste on my part. Jia makes urgent and complex movies about his rapidly and bizarrely evolving country and its leading role within late 20th century/early 21st century global culture — what critic Jonathan Rosenbaum might call “state-of-the-planet addresses.” To be confronted with works of art this new, however, can be a bit bewildering, not unlike the 21st century itself, pushing even a seasoned cinephile like me out of my typical patterns of response and judgement. Having said that, I have no reservation about calling A Touch of Sin the best film I’ve seen all year after only one viewing. A big part of what has made Jia’s latest more immediately accessible than most of his previous work, at least for me personally, is the way he makes the difficulty in adapting to modern life the explicit theme of the film. For this reason, and many others, anyone who cares about not just cinema but what it means to be a global citizen today should see this as soon as possible, and on the big screen if possible.


The four narratives comprising A Touch of Sin are linked not only by main characters who seem unable to adapt to changing times, a bit like Monica Vitti’s character in Red Desert, but also by how their various repressed frustrations lead to acts of shocking violence: a small-town resident fed up with corruption (Jiang Wu), snaps and goes on a killing spree of local politicians and business leaders; a loner in a Chicago Bulls stocking cap (Wang Baoqiang) methodically plans a robbery that seems to be merely an excuse to shoot other people, which provides him with some kind of cathartic release; a receptionist at a massage parlor (Zhao Tao), reeling from a doomed affair with a married man, stabs an overly-aggressive client; and a young man who works a series of factory and service-industry jobs in the “free trade zone” of southern China (Luo Lanshan) commits suicide by jumping to his death from the balcony of his factory dorm. Although the stories are presented consecutively and not freely intercut in the manner of Griffith, the idea of binding a quartet of stories primarily based on thematic parallels is at least as old as 1916’s Intolerance (which, thanks to the Cohen Media Group, had a triumphant re-release in 2013). What’s most shocking, indeed groundbreaking, about A Touch of Sin, has nothing to do with narrative structure nor any one of its individual moments of carnage but rather the way each eruption of violence seems the inevitable result of social, political and economic shifts, mostly relating to the PRC’s transition from the financial wasteland of the post-Cultural Revolution years to an economic superpower still in the process of privatizing and expanding: rural workers flock to big cities in search of decent wages but find their new environment dehumanizing, ordinary citizens file petitions that fall on deaf government ears, women working temp jobs to make ends meet are harassed by wealthy businessmen with an overdeveloped sense of entitlement. What’s a fellow who’s mad as hell but cannot take it anymore to do but wrap a towel emblazoned with the image of a tiger around the barrel of a rifle and take matters into his own hands? This exquisite touch, which occurs in the film’s first story, is a nod to Ti Lung’s Tiger Killer Wu Sung character in Chang Cheh’s The Water Margin (1972), the first of several wuxia nods in A Touch of Sin.


If it seems surprising that a film so explicitly critical of what the Chinese Communist government and big business are doing to its people could be made with full state-approval, perhaps the quote at the beginning of this review (which allegedly occurred during a dinner conversation between Xi Jinping and an American diplomat several years before Xi became President) provides an explanation of how that could happen. It is more likely, however, that the Chinese film industry, which is becoming privatized along with most other sectors of Chinese business, is steadily relaxing the censorship laws that would have made the existence of A Touch of Sin unthinkable even a a decade ago (all of Jia’s work prior to The World was created independently and without government permission). That he is now making high-profile movies like this — artistically accomplished (it is shot in long-take tableaux by the great Yu Lik Wai), psychologically acute and sociologically prescient — is the strongest proof yet that a sea change is underway in Chinese cinema. I have long admired Hong Kong movies (since the pre-handover glory days) as well as those from Taiwan, and have also long been skeptical of their counterparts coming from the mainland, which tend to be safer affairs, if not outright propaganda. I’ve bitterly watched the decline of the Hong Kong film industry since 1997 and have feared that the special magic once produced by the “Hollywood of the East” would be lost forever as even the handful of Hong Kong filmmakers who have remained at home have increasingly had to look to the PRC for co-production status. As Hong Kong becomes inexorably reabsorbed by the mainland (it will supposedly cease to function as a capitalist system in 2047), however, it seems as though China may end up becoming more like Hong Kong rather than the other way around. Johnnie To’s Drug War, the first of the director’s films to be shot entirely in the mainland and every bit the equal of his great Hong Kong productions, is one encouraging sign of this. Whatever happens, when people look back at 2013 decades from now, I wonder if any snapshot of our time in any medium will look as vital as Jia’s forward-looking masterpiece.

You can view the trailer for A Touch of Sin below: 

14 responses to “Now Playing: A Touch of Sin

  • Daniel Nava

    I also saw this at the Music Box this weekend. I was quite impressed, if not quite as smitten as you. It’s my first experience with Zhang-ke and if I were to describe the film in a word it’d be bold. Have you seen NEIGHBORING SOUNDS? I saw A TOUCH OF SIN as a blend of that and A HISTORY OF VIOLENCE.

    Anyway, great piece.

    • michaelgloversmith

      Thanks, Daniel. I loved NEIGHBORING SOUNDS and I totally understand the link you see between it (and A HISTORY OF VIOLENCE) and A TOUCH OF SIN. They’re all about violent eruptions that stem from the collision between the past and the present, no? NEIGHBORING SOUNDS and A TOUCH OF SIN will both be making my “Ten Best of 2013″ list.

  • John Charet

    Great review. I am looking forward to seeing a film by Chinese filmmaker Jia Zhang-ke. I can not wait for this to come out. I believe in Jonathan Rosenbaum’s latest Top 10 favorite film list (released during the 2012 updated Sight & Sound film poll), he placed a Zhang-ke film some place on his list. Although you probably already know my opinion of Asian cinema (I think very highly of it), I was wondering what you think of the action of Hong Kong master John Woo, a director I am a huge fan of. Cheers:)

    • michaelgloversmith

      Do you mean you cannot wait for this to “come out” on DVD/Blu-ray? Because it’s playing at the Music Box right now. I like John Woo’s Hong Kong films quite a bit, especially A BETTER TOMORROW, but not anything he’s done since. Incidentally, Jia pays explicit homage to A BETTER TOMORROW in STILL LIFE (in a shot of a dude lighting a cigarette with a counterfeit bill). Man, my “Best of 2013″ list is getting crowded and I still haven’t seen BASTARDS, WADJDA or THE WOLF OF WALL STREET!

  • John Charet

    My mistake, I can not wait for it to come out on DVD/Blu-ray. Thank you for correcting me:) Hopefully, their will be a way for me to see it at the Music Box I hope. Also, The Wolf of Wall Street will not be released until Christmas Day. P.S. Even though Thanksgiving is not until tomorrow, I want to wish you a Happy Thanksgiving:)

  • Top Ten Films of 2013 | White City Cinema

    […] Mainland China’s greatest contemporary filmmaker, Jia Zhang-ke, made what is arguably his most vital film to date with this angry, occasionally shocking work of social criticism, in which four loosely connected stories are used to show how the collaboration between the Chinese Communist government and big business is wreaking havoc on the lives of ordinary Chinese citizens. Each story culminates in an act of tragic violence (all of which were apparently based on real events) while also paying deft homage to the “honor killings” that permeate the wuxia classics of yesteryear (beginning with King Hu’s A Touch of Zen, from which Jia’s movie derives its punning title). Shot by Jia’s longtime cinematographer, the great Yu Lik Wai, these stories unfold in long shot/long take tableaux that dazzle with their cinematic sophistication while also reinforcing the notion of tragic inevitability suggested by the circular narrative structure. Out of all the films I saw this year, this is the one that I suspect will be of the most interest in a few decades time when future cinephiles want to know what the year 2013 was like. Full review here. […]

  • Odds and Ends: A Touch of Sin | White City Cinema

    […] to Kino/Lorber’s stellar new Blu-ray, an occasion that caused me to realize how much my initial long review barely scratched the surface of this great work of art. Upon rewatching Jia’s bold, funny, […]

  • hijab tutorial dian pelangi

    Howdy! Do you know if they make any plugins to safeguard against hackers?

    I’m kinda paranoid about losing everything I’ve worked hard on.
    Any suggestions?, http://goo.gl/dSTn2Y

  • video lucu banget bikin ketawa

    Thanks very interesting blog!, http://goo.gl/aXlHcP

  • car crashes

    Hi! I’ve been following your weblog for a while now and finally
    got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Kingwood
    Texas! Just wanted to mention keep up the great work!, http://goo.gl/is8ohW

  • video lucu bikin ngakak

    For the reason that the admin of this site is working, no doubt very quickly it
    will be well-known, due to its quality contents., http://goo.gl/Zu4fHG

  • people are awesome sport edition

    Very soon this web site will be famous among all blogging visitors, due to
    it’s good articles, http://goo.gl/ypqAN3

  • funny cats hq

    Pretty! This has been a really wonderful post. Thanks for supplying these details., http://tinyurl.com/m863fq2

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,787 other followers

%d bloggers like this: